Happily

Joel McHale

as

Tom

Kerry Bishé

as

Janet

Natalie Zea

as

Karen

Paul Scheer

as

Val Duffield

Natalie Morales

as

Patricia

Jon Daly

as

Donald

Kirby Howell-B...

as

Maude

Shannon Woodwa...

as

Carla

Charlyne Yi

as

Gretel

Breckin Meyer

as

Richard

Al Madrigal

as

Arthur

Stephen Root

as

Goodman

Billie Wolff

as

Waitress

Brea Grant

as

Cashier