An American Crime

Elliot Page

as

Sylvia Likens

Catherine Keen...

as

Gertrude Banis...

Hayley McFarla...

as

Jennifer Faye ...

Nick Searcy

as

Lester Likens

Romy Rosemont

as

Betty Likens

Ari Graynor

as

Paula Baniszew...

Scout Taylor-C...

as

Stephanie Bani...

Tristan Jarred

as

Johnny Banisze...

Hannah Leigh

as

Shirley Banisz...

Bradley Whitfo...

as

Prosecutor

James Franco

as

Andy

Scott Eastwood

as

Eric

Michael O'Keefe

as

Reverend Bill ...

Carlie Westerm...

as

Marie Baniszew...

Michelle Benes

as

Hope Orbach

Jeremy Sumpter

as

Coy Hubbard

Brian Geraghty

as

Bradley

Channing Nicho...

as

Patty

Michael Welch

as

Teddy

Evan Peters

as

Ricky Hobbs

Amy Ferguson

as

Sally

Will Carter

as

Officer Waters

Edward James G...

as

Bailiff

Patricia Place

as

Mrs. Doyle

Paul Grace

as

Cottin Candy V...

James Meehan

as

Defense Attorn...

Paul Palo

as

Newspaper Repo...

Gary Sievers

as

Carnie (uncred...