Colin Fitz

Matt McGrath

as

Paul

Andy Fowle

as

Grady

William H. Macy

as

Mr. O'Day

John C. McGinl...

as

Groundskeeper

Julianne Phill...

as

Justice Fitz

Will McCormack

as

Todd

Robert Bella

as

Pepe

Erik Jensen

as

Dean

Mary McCormack

as

Moira

Martha Plimpton

as

Ann

Chris Bauer

as

Tony Baby Shark

Kristen Johnst...

as

Stalker Fan

Marley Shelton

as

Crying Fan

Josh Pais

as

Cathartic Fan

Zosia Mamet

as

Lost Fan

Ajax

as

The Dog

Casper Andreas

as

Mats(as Casper...

Julie Auerbach

as

Neck-brace Fan...

Craig Collingt...

as

Fan

Bret Bella

as

Interviewer

Adam Bitterman

as

Prediction Fan

Kate Blumberg

as

Shining Star F...

Brendan Bradley

as

Unofficial Cov...

Patrick Breen

as

Lonely Fan

Christopher Ca...

as

Lonely Fan

Erin Chandler

as

Ditsy Fan

Harry Clein

as

Jewish Music F...

Ridley May Dow...

as

Immaculate Con...

Sharon Raab Do...

as

Immaculate Con...

Timothy Durkin

as

Fan

Matt Flanders

as

Smoking Fan

Matt Flanders

as

Unofficial Cov...

Giada Hansen

as

Shower Fan

George Hertzbe...

as

Married Hippy ...

Nancy Hower

as

Guitar Chick F...

Antti Kaarlela

as

Concert Announ...

Harry Jay Know...

as

Velvet Poster ...

Jordan Lage

as

The J-Man Fan

Paul Marcarelli

as

Magical Fan #1

Mary B. McCann

as

Bickering Wife...

Heather Oakley

as

Dolphin Fan

Toni Pearen

as

Pandemonium Fan

Lena Pepe

as

Daughter of Bi...

Neil Pepe

as

Bickering Husb...

Jenni Pulos

as

Loving Fan

Olivia Rosewood

as

Toy Piano Fan

Reed Ruby

as

Fan

Mark Schwahn

as

Venice Beach F...

Cynthia Silver

as

Magical Fan #2

Mark Souza

as

Unofficial Cov...

Krista Tucker

as

Married Hippy ...

Paul Urcioli

as

Vics and Tims ...

Todd Weeks

as

Toilet Fan

Ali Humiston

as

Teddy Bear Fan...

Marc Opitz

as

Fan(uncredited)